McGee's Musings

  Sunday, January 30, 2005

Help build the GTD Wiki

Looks as though it's just getting off the ground, but it could easily develop into an important resource. Check it out.

Help build the GTD Wiki. Jeff Sandquist and some of his buddies at Microsoft just had a visit from David Allen. Coming to the realization that there are so many sources of information about the Getting Things Done system scattered about the net, they decided a wiki would be a good idea. And they also decided that keeping it tucked behind a firewall at Microsoft would limit the potential value it might offer. So Jeff has issued a public call to help build the GTD Wiki he's hosting.

I know many readers of this blog are avid GTD'ers. Please stop by Jeff's Wiki and see what you can contribute. [Marc's Outlook on Productivity]
10:11:01 PM •  • 

  Friday, January 28, 2005

Lippman and Reed on Viral Networking

Let me add my recommendation to Martin's and add that the paper is authored by David Reed and Andy Lippman of MIT. I've mentioned David's work from time to time and Andy is equally brilliant and insightful.

A fatal infection. I would urge readers to drop the baby, turn off the oven, sit down and read this MIT paper on viral networking. In a nutshell, it describes the future of mesh networks. There are two core results: Throughput increases with... [Telepocalypse]
7:30:31 PM •  • 

  Thursday, January 27, 2005

How to read a business book

Solid advice from Brendon on how to get the most out of any non-fiction book. Some tips and tricks I will want to incorporate into my habits.

How to read a business book. I'll be honest here, this isn't just for reading business books. What I'm going to cover ought to suffice for pretty much any physical text from which you wish to squeeze maximum value. This isn't a how-to on studying though...there... [Slacker Manager]

UPDATE: Through a cut and paste error (mine) the original title on this made no sense - so I fixed it
9:44:36 PM •  • 
More on the IT cultural divide

I agree. This is a pointer to an excellent piece on technology and business change, full of insight and good advice.

Spooky Action: Seldom updated, often re-read



Mike DeWitt is a guy who needs a kick in the ass. He writes such good stuff, then gets taken prisoner by work for 6 months at a stretch. (Disclaimer: We chat from time to time, but I'm serious, this is not blogrolling.) This here post alone will sort the boyz from the men, girlz from the women on an executive mangement team. And - gasp - it's fun to read.


Spooky Action Predicts: Nick Carr has your number! (.8 probability)



If you’re in IT management or consulting, your blood pressure is now 40 points higher than before you got here. If you’re a CEO/CFO/CXO whose span of control includes IT, you may have one of those wry, one-corner-of-your-mouth-turned-up smiles on your face. If you’re none of the above, a) Hi Mom kids!, or b) thanks for stopping by randomly; I hope I make it worth your while....


9:42:52 PM •  • 
New ESJ column on the IT cultural divide

Part two of my column on Bridging the IT Cultural Divide, Part 2 is up at ESJ. This installment looks at the issue from the side of management. The first column, Bridging the IT Cultural Divide, Part 1, started from the techie's perspective.

11:01:08 AM •  • 

  Tuesday, January 25, 2005

Donate your unused CPU time to cancer research

Worth a few cycles of your time to decide whether you've got some resources worth sharing.

Are you one of those people who has one or more computers running all the time? Check out the story posted on The Cancer Blog today about a new effort to use spare CPU cycles to assist the Human Proteome Folding Project, which will bring many insights into cancer research.





grid.org

4:48:07 PM •  • 
Contracting, clarity, and requirements

I've certainly been guilty of this kind of approach at multiple points throughout my career. The best techniques I've encountered for dealing with these challenges are the "contracting" conversations that Peter Block advocates so strongly in his excellent Flawless Consulting: A Guide to Getting Your Expertise Used. Regardless of which side of the table you are on, you had better become more adept at Block's contracting or you will be building or paying for entirely too many custom-made drywall saws.

There's an amazing essay at The Spurious Pundit on "Picture Hanging." It's an allegory that explores how simple requirements in software aren't that obvious to folks who may not have context. The writing is wonderful, do check it out, it's worth your time. Subscribed.

A highlight:

You tell him to hang the photo of your pet dog, and he comes back a week later, asking if you could "just double-check" his design for a drywall saw.

"Why are you designing a drywall saw?"
"Well, the wood saw in the office toolbox isn't good for cutting drywall."
"What, you think you're the first person on earth to try and cut drywall? You can buy a saw for that at Home Depot."
"Okay, cool, I'll go get one."
"Wait, why are you cutting drywall in the first place?"
"Well, I wasn't sure what the best practices for hanging pictures were, so I went online and found a newsgroup for gallery designers. And they said that the right way to do it was to cut through the wall, and build the frame into it. That way, you put the picture in from the back, and you can make the glass much more secure since you don't have to move it. It's a much more elegant solution than that whole nail thing."
"..."

This metaphor may be starting to sound particularly fuzzy, but trust me - there are very real parallels to draw here. If you haven't seen them yet in your professional life, you will. [Spurious Pundit]

4:44:58 PM •  • 
The perfectionist definition of "good enough"

I have worked for entirely too many perfectionists in my life. That includes times when I've worked for myself. In a world of potentially open-ended assignments, we all need to be giving a lot more thought to how we define and recognize "good enough."

The perfectionist definition of "good enough". A while back I was working with a client who had a serious perfectionist streak. One session, as we were talking about the lack of satisfaction with anything this client did, I said, "Do you know what I think your... [The Occupational Adventure (sm)]
4:35:34 PM •  • 

  Monday, January 24, 2005

What You'll Wish You'd Known

Another great essay from Paul Graham.

What You'll Wish You'd Known. Paul's advice to high school students. [Paul Graham]
11:17:06 PM •  • 
BlogWalk Chicago Reflections

I spent an excellent day Saturday with both old and new blogging friends at BlogWalk Chicago. Jack Vinson and AKMA have good overview posts and more can be found at BlogWalk TopicExchange and Technorati tag:BlogWalk. With some luck I will find some time to process much of the excellent conversation and output of the day.

One conversation thread that wound in and out of the day was the relation of blogs and social software to large organizations. Tom Sherman struggled with this discussion and I thought it worth taking a few moments to try and articulate my perspective.One reality for most of us is that we can expect to spend a substantial portion of our time in and around large organizations. I believe they will be part of our work landscape for some time to come. The nature of the work expected of many of us is evolving rapidly. It's more fluid and less well-defined. Job descriptions, when they are available, don't provide a lot of guidance.

At the same time the mythology around organizations and work is that there should be clear guidelines around what is expected of us. I know that I struggle with these uncertainties routinely. Most of the day to day work that leads up to knowledge products and deliverables is fundamentally invisible. The bits that make up email and draft documents and spreadsheet models are hidden and shared only among a handful of people until they are completed. More than anything else, what blogs and social software do is make it drop dead simple to make the conduct of knowledge work visible. To me this is of fundamental importance. Knowledge work depends on our ability to learn and improve as we go. That depends on being able to see what is going on and social software makes that feasible.

Organizations struggle with the notion that they need to learn. Too often, learning is something that someone else in the organization needs to do. Moreover, real learning (as opposed to what passes for learning in too many training environments) is a social activity. These tools will be central to creating the environment in which necessary learning can take place. Today, that learning activity is almost exclusively the province of those who've retained their natural curiosity and inquisitiveness in spite of eduational and organizational systems that work overtime to suppress these natural instincts. The work that needs to be done will force the rest of us to adapt as well. Seems to me that working out this transition presents some interesting work to be done inside organizations.
11:10:38 PM •  • 

  Thursday, January 20, 2005

Column at Enterprise Systems Journal.

This week marks the start of a new sideline for me. Jim Powell, editor of Enterprise Systems Journal, has asked me to write a column for them covering the same kinds of material I talk about here. The first column, Bridging the IT Cultural Divide, ran earlier this week. In it I start to explore an idea I've been trying to work out about oral vs. literate styles of thinking as they relate to organizations.

Thanks to the indefatigable Buzz Bruggeman for brokering the introduction. And thanks to Jim Powell for his efforts at edting.
9:27:47 PM •  • 

  Monday, January 17, 2005

Copyrighted paintings - less to the story than meets the eye

Another "isn't the establishment evil and stupid story?" One paragraph after what's quoted here is the following from the original story:

Actually, the museum guard was mistaken. There was no copyright issue, and the museum apologizes and is telling artists to sketch away as long as they do not interrupt the flow of traffic in the always crowded gallery.

So perhaps we have a training issue or a somewhat overzealous and underinformed guard. Is this selective sharing of the story helpful? You know that this would have disappeared in a heartbeat if fully reported, while selective quotation gave it some blog legs. Isn't there enough actual dumb behavior out there that we can let this one pass?

Stop sketching, little girl -- those paintings are copyrighted!. Xeni Jardin: Museum security guard told a child to stop sketching paintings in a museum -- because they're copyrighted.

It is standard operating procedure for students of art to learn by example by sketching masterpieces in an art museum. A budding artist in Durham found that the time honored tradition was challenged while seeking inspiration at the Matisse, Picasso and the School of Paris: Masterpieces from the Baltimore Museum of Art exhibit in Raleigh.

Over the weekend at the North Carolina Museum of Art there were works by Matisse, Picasso, Monet, Degas and some Illanas. Julia Illana is a second grader who was visiting the popular exhibit there with her parents and was sketching the paintings in her notebook. "I love to draw in my notebook," Illana said.

Her sketch of Picasso's Woman with Bangs, which came out pretty good, and Matisse's Large Reclining Nude got the promising artist into trouble with museum security. A museum guard told Julia's parents that sketching was prohibited because the great masterpieces are copyright protected, a concept that young Julia did not understand until her mother explained the term.

6:35:28 PM •  • 
Edward Tufte on presenting evidence

More insights from Tufte on how to be an intelligent consumer of data. At the same time, you would do well to take Tufte's observations with at least a grain of salt.

The tools of rhetoric precede those of data analysis by more than a few centuries and Tufte is a master of both. Tufte appears to see malice and venality in settings where I see predictable organizational pressures of time and cost. With the luxury of tenure, Tufte can find the all too real flaws in analyses prepared in the face of these pressures.

Tufte's guidelines and analyses are all worth contemplating. What would be intriguing is to understand what tools he would substitute for those (such as PowerPoint and Excel) he criticizes so harshly. Further, once we've learned to recognize the analytical flaws he identifies, what do we do next in order to learn to commit them less frequently?

Tufte's new chapter, Corrupt Techniques in Evidence Presentations, from his forthcoming book Beautiful Evidence, is now online for a month.

"Here is the first of several chapters on consuming presentations, on what alert members of an audience or readers of a report should look for in assessing the credibility of the presenter."
6:15:18 PM •  • 

  Thursday, January 13, 2005

Jeff Bezos interview in Wired

An interesting interview with Bezos. To me the most interesting thing he said was:

I'm not saying that advertising is going away. But the balance is shifting. If today the successful recipe is to put 70 percent of your energy into shouting about your service and 30 percent into making it great, over the next 20 years I think that's going to invert.

I do think that current advertising models are obsolete and that few have figured out that that means for their businesses.

Jeff Bezos on the Zen of Sales. The cool head of Amazon.com talks about the rise of the obscure, taking on Netflix and why he quit spending on TV advertising. By Chris Anderson from Wired magazine. [Wired News]
11:02:15 PM •  • 
Barriers to entry

I miss Calvin and Hobbes.

10:58:50 PM •  • 
AKMA on organizational change

Who knew that AKMA was an organizational theorist in addition to being a scholar and a preacher? Profound insight into change and change management expressed far more succinctly and usefully than most of the organizational change material you will usually encounter.

When trying to simplify a complex [bureaucratic] system, any change that does not result in an obvious quantum of simplification amounts to further complication — or, more concisely, “any attempted simplification short of a quantum change is always a complication.”

4:31:05 PM •  • 

  Saturday, January 08, 2005

GM, Windows, and blogging

Given that GM has started blogging, this made a well-timed appearance in my aggregator.

If Cars Worked Like Windows. This has been floating around the 'Net for a long time, but it's been a while since I've seen it. I laughed out loud when I read it again, so I thought you might enjoy it.

Bill Gates reportedly compared the computer industry with the auto industry and stated, "If GM ... [Blogarithms]
4:27:51 PM •  • 

  Friday, January 07, 2005

Pro metadata will lose to folksonomy

Not only does Shirky nail it, but Cory hones in on the money graf s for us. This is clearly one of a class of problems where scaling issues overwhelm other factors and force solutions to be somehow distributed.

These are much like the situation in the early days of long-distance telephone service that needed operators to complete all calls. Analyses at the time predicted that the services would fail because your clearly were going to need to hire so many operators that the system would collapse. The solution, in that case, was to effectively make everyone an operator by inventing direct-dial long distance and area codes. Of course, we've now reached the point where area codes are an anachronism and have little predictive value about where the phone in question exists in the physical universe.

Shirky: Pro metadata will lose to folksonomy. Cory Doctorow: Clay Shirky continues to just totally nail the questions of metadata, authority, and user-created content. Today's installment: why crappy, cheap, user-generated, uncontrolled metadata will win out over expensive, controlled, useful, professionally generated metadata:
Furthermore, users pollute controlled vocabularies, either because they misapply the words, or stretch them to uses the designers never imagined, or because the designers say "Oh, let's throw in an 'Other' category, as a fail-safe" which then balloons so far out of control that most of what gets filed gets filed in the junk drawer. Usenet blew up in exactly this fashion, where the 7 top-level controlled categories were extended to include an 8th, the 'alt.' hierarchy, which exploded and came to dwarf the entire, sanctioned corpus of groups.

The cost of finding your way through 60K photos tagged 'summer', when you can use other latent characteristics like 'who posted it?' and 'when did they post it?', is nothing compared to the cost of trying to design a controlled vocabulary and then force users to apply it evenly and universally.

This is something the 'well-designed metadata' crowd has never understood -- just because it's better to have well-designed metadata along one axis does not mean that it is better along all axes, and the axis of cost, in particular, will trump any other advantage as it grows larger. And the cost of tagging large systems rigorously is crippling, so fantasies of using controlled metadata in environments like Flickr are really fantasies of users suddenly deciding to become disciples of information architecture.



If you want to trace back to some of the items that launched this most recent disscussion, here are some of the key links:

11:27:37 PM •  • 
50 book challenge results for 2004

I did manage to read just over 50 books during 2004. If I were feeling exceptionally compulsive, I could go back and complete reviews of all of them, but the value for that isn't clear.
I expect to manage a comparable reading load in 2005. In the interests of making this blog a better back up brain for myself, I plan on keeping better running notes on the nonfiction titles as I read. Whether I bother to write up details for my fiction read remains to be seen.
One thing I plan to do over the next week or so is to identify the top five or so books that I found most valuable in 2004. For the record these are the books I fnished in 2004.
  1. Heinlein's For Us the Living - 50 Book Challenge
  2. Christensen's Innovator's Solution - 50 Book Challenge
  3. David Allen's Ready for Anything - 50 Book Challenge
  4. David Gerrold's The Man Who Folded Himself - 50 Book Challenge
  5. Dan Brown's Deception Point - 50 Book Challenge
  6. Dan Brown's Digital Fortress - 50 Book Challenge
  7. Richard Morgan's Altered Carbon - 50 Book Challenge
  8. John Brunner's Shockware Rider - 50 Book Challenge
  9. Robert Wilson's Chronoliths - 50 Book Challenge
  10. Bruce Sterling's Zenith Angle - 50 Book Challenge
  11. John McPhee's Curve of Binding Energy - 50 Book Challenge
  12. Lawrence Lessig's Free Culture - 50 Book Challenge
  13. John Brunner's The Sheep Look Up - 50 Book Challenge
  14. Greg Iles's The Footprints of God - 50 Book Challenge
  15. Steven Johnson's Mind Wide Open - 50 Book Challenge
  16. Anderson, Poul - For Love and Glory
  17. Charles Stross's Iron Sunrise - 50 Book Challenge
  18. Brian Arkill's LDAP Directories Explained - 50 Book Challenge
  19. Eric Meyer's Cascading Style Sheets: The Definitive Guide, 2nd Ed - 50 Book Challenge
  20. Eric Meyer on CSS - 50 Book Challenge
  21. Gregory Dicum's Window Seat - 50 Book Challenge
  22. Todd Carter's Microsoft OneNote 2003 for Windows - 50 Book Challenge
  23. Dvorak and Pirillo's Online! The Book - 50 Book Challenge
  24. Charles Stross's Singularity Sky - 50 book challenge
  25. Elizabeth Moon's Trading in Danger - 50 Book Challenge
  26. Austin, Robert - Artful Making: What Managers Need to Know About How Artists Work
  27. Cadenhead, Rogers - Radio UserLand Kick Start
  28. Caldwell, Ian - The Rule of Four
  29. Carr, Nicholas G. - Does IT Matter? Information Technology and the Corrosion of Competitive Advantage
  30. Hammond, Grant T. - The Mind of War: John Boyd and American Security
  31. Kelly, Kevin - Cool Tools
  32. Lakoff, George - Don't Think of an Elephant: Know Your Values and Frame the Debate--The Essential Guide for Progressives
  33. Modesitt, L. E. - Archform: Beauty
  34. MORIARTY, CHRIS - Spin State
  35. Ringo, John - Emerald Sea
  36. Ringo, John - There Will Be Dragons
  37. Ringo, John - Cally's War
  38. Stross, Charles - The Atrocity Archives
  39. Tharp, Twyla - The Creative Habit: Learn It and Use It for Life
  40. Wheaton, Wil - Just a Geek
  41. Wurman, Richard Saul - Information Anxiety 2
  42. Yamashita, Keith - Unstuck: A tool for Yourself, Your Team , and Your World
  43. Zackheim, Sarah Parsons - Getting Your Book Published for Dummies
  44. Bok, Derek Curtis - Universities in the Marketplace: The Commercialization of Higher Education
  45. Camp, Jim - Start with NO...The Negotiating Tools that the Pros Don't Want You to Know
  46. Graham, Paul - Hackers and Painters: Big Ideas from the Computer Age
  47. Weber, David - The Shadow of Saganami (The Saganami Island)
  48. Brand, Stewart - How Buildings Learn; What Happens After They're Built
  49. Kawasaki, Guy - The Art Of The Start: The Time-Tested, Battle-Hardened Guide For Anyone Starting Anything
  50. Cussler, Clive - Black Wind
  51. Modesitt, L. E. - Flash
  52. LAMOTT, ANNE - Bird by Bird : Some Instructions on Writing and Life
  53. Stross, Charles - Toast
10:49:38 PM •  • 

  Thursday, January 06, 2005

Whereas I am about as nerdy as I suspected

Whereas I score even higher - age and a mind for trivia seem to help as well.


I am
nerdier than 93% of all people. Are you nerdier? Click here to find
out!

Wow! I'm more of a nerd than I thought!. Another one of those silly quizzes but I was really quite surprised by my score in this one.





I am nerdier than 79% of all people. Are you nerdier? Click here to find out!



[The Office Weblog]
5:39:28 PM •  • 

  Tuesday, January 04, 2005

More RSS converts

RSS bigots of the world unite! This is another of those 'you need to experience it to understand it' kinds of phenomena.

rss, where are thou?

"Syndication is key. I have become such a snob that I won't read a blog if I can't dump it into my BlogLines account. Okay, snob is a bit harsh. It is more about convenience. I don't have time to search out every nifty blog I come across every day to see if there is a new post. I want it delivered to me. When I find a new blog I enjoy, the first thing I do is scour the sidebars for a link to syndication. No syndication, no subscription. The blogger loses out on higher readership & I lose out on reading some awesome posts. And so I'll end with a simple plea to all bloggers - check your sidebar. Do you link to your feed? Is it easy to find? If not, why?" [so this is mass communication?, via Scripting News]

Kaye, you're not alone! In fact, I think we need a badge....

Update: heh… Paul Beard answered the call. Here’s an “RSS Bigot” badge! I’ve added it to my pages at the bottom of the right-hand column. Thanks, Paul!

RSS Bigot

11:23:55 PM •  • 
Thesauri links

A useful resource.

Here's a nice collection of links on thesauri, taxonomies, ontologies and facets.

11:19:31 PM •  • 

  Monday, January 03, 2005

The purity of the English language

And thank you Suw!

The purity of the English language. "The problem with defending the purity of the English language is that English is about as pure as a cribhouse whore. We don't just borrow words; on occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and rifle their pockets for new vocabulary."


- James D. Nicoll

"English is the result of Norman men-at-arms attempting to pick up Saxon barmaids and is no more legitimate than any of the other results."


- H. Beam Piper



(Thanks Kate!)
[Chocolate and Vodka]


11:10:43 PM •  • 

  Sunday, January 02, 2005

An Enormous Collection of Crossword Puzzles

As if I didn't have enough ways to procrastinate already.

An Enormous Collection of Crossword Puzzles. You like crossword puzzles? You REALLY like crossword puzzles? How about over 32,000 of them? That's what you'll find at http://www.crosswordpuzzlegames.com/ . The crossword puzzles are divided up into several... [ResearchBuzz]
9:24:47 PM •  • 

  Saturday, January 01, 2005

Reflections on Getting Things Done at 43 Folders

Excellent set of reflections on David Allen's Getting Things Done thinking and adapting it to different kinds of knowledge worker.

This is the final installment of a three-part series looking back on a year of doing Getting Things Done. Part 1: The Good Stuff; Part 2: The Stuff I Wish I Were Better At.

[43 Folders]
6:38:18 PM •  •